Brother, can you spare a brook trout?

When a friend asks an angler to take their 23 year-old nephew from out of town fishing, an angler feels obligated honored to do so. Immediately after committing to said act of selfless generosity, the angler begins to wonder just what they may have gotten themselves into. The angler’s imagination runs rampant, fueled by speculation, curiosity and anxiety. What will said nephew of this friend be like? About all the angler is told is that the nephew is fairly new to fly fishing and would really like to get out and wet a line. The angler ponders what, in this case, “fairly new” means. I can mean one of several things:

  • Said nephew has fly fished a few times
  • Said nephew has gripped a fly rod once
  • Said nephew has watched A River Runs Through It, and wants to do ‘that’

More significant than the experience level is the type of person said nephew turns out to be. The angler wonders at the nearly countless possibilities, and speculation is vast:

  • Said nephew is painfully quiet and socially awkward, making conversation difficult
  • Said nephew is an ill-mannered punk, representative of the worst that the generation of entitlement has to offer
  • Said nephew is horribly offended by the occasional colorful expletive
  • Said nephew doesn’t drink beer

While en route to the rendezvous point to meet said nephew, the angler is deep in wonder; thoughts dominated by one:  What the hell did I get myself into?

If appearances alone are any indication, my anxiety was immediately reduced.  Said nephew, whose name shall be “Dan” from here on out, appeared to be quite normal looking. No piercings or visible crazy tattoos. No that there’s anything wrong with tattoos–I mean, heck, all the kids are doing it, right? His social skills were above normal without coming on too strong. A good firm handshake and eye contact.  Someone had raised this young man properly.

We loaded his gear into the back of the Fish Taco and made our way east on I-90 toward our destination. We didn’t have a long drive so awkward silences wouldn’t be intolerable. However, the conversation came easily. It also came with some very interesting discoveries.  Turns out we shared a common bond: we were are both Eagle Scouts. I’ve met only a small handful of Eagle Scouts over the years; not surprising given that the achievement takes a lot of hard work and dedication (not many teenagers are interested in that). I’ve never met an Eagle Scout I didn’t like (not sure that they’ve been able to say the same about me).

The conversation moved naturally from one topic to another and as it did so it revealed that Dan and I also brothers. Not in the familial sense, but fraternally. He attended Oklahoma State University recently while I attended Washington State University not so recently. During our years at respective state universities, we were both members of the same fraternity: Sigma Nu. From that point forward we were like old college buddies. Sort of. A generation gap did divide our college experiences, but we had a bond.

Auntie Em–we’re not in Oklahoma anymore.

We fished an easily-accessed section of the South Fork Snoqualmie River that lies within full view, and earshot, of I-90. While perhaps not quite the back-country fishing experience Dan may have hoped for, it was a delightful afternoon to be doing something other than work, or mowing the lawn.  My favorite nearby rivers are still running high due to La Niña’s ferocity this past winter/spring. The high flows are good for the fish, bad for the impatient angler. The South Fork levels were looking pretty favorable. I warned Dan that we would not be stalking trophy trout.

I armed Dan with my Sage Launch 4 weight, and we began with some casting instruction. Dan had done a little stick waving prior to our outing, but not much.  I explained the basics of waiting for the rod to load, about presenting the fly, mending to get a drag-free drift, yadda, yadda, yadda. I explained about current seams and what to look for. Fish the foam! After a while of me hovering, the best thing for me to do was leave him alone so he could relax and get the hang of it. He did.

First bend in the rod.

After a few missed opportunities Dan eventually set the hook on a fish: a 5 inch brook trout. I’ve yet to catch a brook trout, and cursed him congratulated him on his accomplishment. A few more missed hooksets followed before he landed a little more respectable fish: an 8 inch brook trout.  Sonofabitch Good for him! I hadn’t caught anything yet, but in my defense I wasn’t really trying.

First trout on the fly…a brookie.

On an Adams.

Interstate 90 is just barely visible in the background.

We worked our way upstream, careful not to bump our heads on the I-90 overpass. We fished more trouty-looking water as I intensely went about my quest for my first brook trout. Dan caught another.  Finally I hooked up with a fish: an 8 inch rainbow. Damnit. To show my angling prowess, I asked if Dan would like to see a wild rainbow trout. He was impressed (or so he pretended to be).

We wrapped up the day with a beer on the tailgate of the Fish Taco before heading into North Bend for a bite to eat (I “pulled chapter number” on him and made him buy my dinner). In the end we had a rather enjoyable day (at least I did). Dan learned a good bit about fly fishing for (brook) trout, made strides to improve his casting, and showed every indication that he is well on his way toward becoming an accomplished angler.  The same cannot be said about me.




  1. Patrick

    I can sympathize with all of those thoughts…heck, while as a fly fishermen I tend to be motivated by the possibilities, I find that the overthinking that comes with the sport can also pepper my mind with doubts and questions.

    BTW, feel free to send me very specific directions and/or GPS coordinates; I’ll be visiting the bro’ up there next week. We’ll be waving rods with Derek Thursday and looking for suspicious water Friday or Saturday, in between beers and antics that come with (possible) temporary bachelorhood.

    …oh yeah, I’m an almost-Eagle Scout (I blame the family move in the middle of my junior year in high school for my unaccomplished-ness in this endeavor) and member of the Order of the Arrow. Still amazes my wife that at this age I can still recite the Scout oath, law, motto and slogan.

    • Kirk Werner

      I’ll gladly give you exact coordinates- hardly a secret spot. However, there are better spots, fairly close-by, that are out of sight and sound of the interstate.

      Get ahold of me while you’re here. Might be able to sneak out on Friday (if I don’t ask, just go!) I’ll even show you the Eagle Scout handshake 😉

  2. Kevin Breen

    This was a hoot to read, Kirk! Really, never hooked Brook? Come on down to NM, where you will get Beookies, Brownies, and Rainbowies all in the same day…and with a lotta luck maybe even a cutthroatie! Yeah, moving back to NM from this Hellhole called Texas! So if you ever feel the need to travel south, maybe fish the famous fishbowl San Juan, or the Animas, Cimmaron, Jemez….etc., you have a camp..and guide…

    • Kirk Werner

      Brook Trouts allude me- in fact, twice in that same location others have caught them while I’ve not. Oh, and I’d love to visit NM sometime. I’ll bring a supply of San Juan Worms- probably can’t find those down there, eh? 😉

  3. Sanders

    I’m just glad you didn’t “pull your chapter number” on him when he came tight to one of those brookies…

    an accomplished mission for sure…well done!

    • Kirk Werner

      Thanks, Sanders- it was tempting but I took the high road for once, and let the young man revel in the glory.

  4. Ed

    After reading your post I have to say that it is rather difficult to concentrate on proper presentation to brook trout when you are actively instructing a new guy. All of your concentration must have been toward ensuring that he was having a good time — all the while sacrificing your opportunity to catch a brookie.

    Your selfless contribution to the furthering of the sport has not gone unnoticed.


    • Kirk Werner

      Ed, I think you’re giving me too much credit 😉 Seriously though, I am glad Dan got into a few fish- that was the goal.

  5. cofisher

    I had a brief but friendly talk with “Dan”. He was wondering what type of person his uncle had set him up with. He did modestly mention that he caught more fish than you did and that you weren’t even funny.!

    Seriously, Kirk great post and good job on helping another good guy get into the sport. You’re my h….well ok, I won’t get carried away.

    • Kirk Werner

      Oh, Howard. Don’t go gettin’ all soft and sentimental on me now–I wouldn’t know how to handle it.

  6. Fontinalis Rising

    Those darn kids. You share all your expertise and they take all the credit. Perhaps the benefit of being a generation ahead is that we know how to finagle free food.

  7. Kevin Redden

    I do most of my stream fishing on the Middle Fork (as I live right on it) and I had fished the South Fork a couple times and had been skunked both times so after I found and read this I decided to give it another go the week before last. I went a little further upstream than I think you were at here, after wading past some likely unproductive water I found some decent spots and managed to get a bunch of fish, with the very last one before heading out being a nice little Brookie.

    Went back a few days later to where I think you guys were and ended up losing count of how many I hooked, all small, but a lot of fun on the 3-weight. Caught one Brookie this time too.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *