UA_header_NEW2011c.jpg

Lawn Trout

by Kirk Werner on September 27, 2011

Fall is officially here and it’s a time of year that many anglers welcome thanks to the emergence of some noteworthy insects. With summer now in the rear-view mirror, hoppers and stones taper off and give way to baetis hatches that bring trout to the surface for some challenging autumnal angling: tiny bugs, light tippet, and water that is—to use an already overused term—gin clear. Another important bug, the October Caddis, offers an important source of calories to fish preparing for the long winter ahead. These large flies, in all their pumpkin-orange splendor, also signal that it’s time for humans to up their caloric intake by consuming vast quantities of completely unnecessary Halloween candy. Case in point: we’ve had exactly 2 trick-or-treaters at our house in 10 years, and yet we’re always somehow prepared with several pounds of candy bars.  Fall is also a time that another insect rears it’s ugly head: The European Crane Fly. They may or may not be prevalent near every trout stream in the world, but if you have a yard with grass you’re likely to witness this abundant fall hatch.

Crane Fly pattern (Galloup's Slide Inn Fly Shop)

The severity of the Crane Fly hatch can vary from year to year, and in my assessment a lot depends on how moist the previous spring was. If the ground in which the grass grows remains damp and cool, a good bountiful fall hatch can be expected. Given how extended and wet our Pacific Northwest Spring was this year thanks to La Niña (a.k.a. “The Bitch”), the Crane Fly hatch taking place right now is—to use another overused term—epic. The nymphal shucks can be seen scattered all over the lawn, and all I have to do is walk through the grass on my daily poop patrol to observe the adults fluttering about in every direction as they hook up with sexual partners before seeking moist, cool areas in which to lay their eggs. If I were to close my eyes I could easily imagine myself walking not across the lawn, but instead wading in a river as fish rise with reckless abandon to pick off these large, clumsy bugs. If I closed my eyes I’d also step in dog shit, so I keep my eyes peeled accordingly. Subsequently I see no fish rising to eat Crane Flies.

Crane Fly nymphal shucks

Consenting adult Crane Flies

Egg laying adult Crane Fly

Crane flies can be the bane of lawn owners and many use pesticides to kill the larvae (a.k.a. “leather jackets”), which may damage a lawn as they feed on the roots of the grass. The grubs are big, thick, meaty, nasty looking maggots that resemble something people would eat on the too-long running television show, Survivor. When densely populated, these grubs can devastate entire sections of lawn.

Crane Fly larva–nom nom nom

In order to control the larvae chemically, I’ve been told to use pesticides in the two months beginning with A: April and August. Apparently using a pesticide in April kills the grubs as they begin to actively feed, and applying again in August kills any grubs not killed in April, before they can hatch, lay eggs, and complete the circle.  I’m generally opposed to using pesticides for obvious reasons, though I have been known in the past to spot treat small areas where the infestation of Crane Fly grubs was heavy. Still, chemicals that will kill bugs will kill other things that we may not want killed, and pollutants run downhill and eventually end up in our streams. Where fish live. As they say over at Recycled Fish, “Our lifestyles run downstream.” So, please read the warning labels before you decide to use chemicals on your lawn. Pesticides bad!

Warning: Read this. No, really.

My opposition to using damaging chemicals recently gave rise to an alternative, organic idea that I think would appeal to many: Lawn Trout. Now I know what you’re saying: “Lawn Trout would be no different than moles, and would subsequently cause collateral damage beyond their benefit.” Before we more closely examine the idea of Lawn Trout, let’s first unearth some information regarding moles.

Lawn damage caused by moles, not Lawn Trout.

As hard as it is to imagine, there is an apparent benefit to having moles in your yard. If you look beneath the cosmetic damage caused by these velvet-coated, tunnel-digging pests, they are (allegedly) beneficial because they aerate the soil and control damaging subterranean insects (such as Crane Fly larvae). While that may supposedly be true, I would say to those who would tout the merits of moles, “You don’t have moles.” Well, I have moles. They’ve caused damage to more sections of my yard than any amount of Crane Flies, and there is no permanent means of keeping moles out of one’s yard, shy of digging a 5 foot deep trench around the perimeter of your property and filling it with concrete (if you do this, make damn sure there are no moles inside the barrier you’re constructing). Moles can be very difficult to trap, although I have had some success in doing so, from which I derived great pleasure. I make no apologies for this.

I hate moles and yes, I killed this one.

But Lawn Trout would not, like moles, burrow under the ground: they would cruise the surface. A Lawn Trout may pick at bugs on the ground and even make redds in your flower gardens, but they would no sooner burrow into the ground than trout burrow into the streambed. It’s a difficult concept to grasp so I’ve included a technical diagram to better illustrate the key differences between Lawn Trout and Moles:

In layman’s terms, you’ll be able to see Lawn Trout, whereas moles are sneaky and cowardly. Imagine, if you will, sitting on the porch proudly gazing out at your yard as Lawn Trout routinely cruise the expanse of lawn, feeding on damaging insects such as Crane Flies. The Lawn Trout would also control the mosquito population, which is problematic in many areas.

Lawn Cutthroat Trout feeding on Crane Fly

Obviously you would want to get up early or be watchful in the evening to observe most Lawn Trout activity, however on rainy, cloudy, miserable days you may even see Lawn Trout during midday as well. If you live where I do, you’ll routinely see Lawn Trout during midday. You may even see them beyond the perimeter of your yard as they venture about in search of food. Be on the alert when driving in Lawn Trout country!

Lawn Trout can brighten even the gloomiest day.

Lawn Trout would be free to come and go as they please, but the yard is where we must focus most of our attention, for it is the yard that will provide critical habitat for and derive the most benefit from Lawn Trout. The natural fish fertilizer would be excellent for the grass and other decorative plantings, unlike feline “Almond Roca” or piles of canine excrement which must be manually removed as it offers absolutely no benefit to one’s yard whatsoever. No need to spend hard-earned money at the hardware store when the same thing at no cost, thanks to Lawn Trout!

Why buy when you can get for free?

And speaking of Almond Roca, a resident Lawn Bull Trout living under your deck would surely solve the problem of the neighbor lady’s cat using your planter beds as its personal litter box.

Lawn Cat Fish?

It’s pretty clear already that the natural benefits of Lawn Trout will make them a welcome addition to any yard, but the presence of these overland salmonids needn’t be a matter of practicality without the potential for play. There’s no reason why lawn casting shouldn’t take on an added dimension: the chance to catch a fish while practicing your double haul!

Lawn casting becomes lawn fishing.

Furthermore, that same backyard sport needn’t stop with the home owner. Instead of chasing tennis balls or cats (if there are any cats left by now), the energetic family dog would be kept highly entertained by the presence of terrestrial pods of trouts. It’s safe to assume that Labradors could easily be taught to fetch and release. That is, if they could even catch a Lawn Trout.

Having a few Lawn Trout around the homestead may not be a substitute for actual fishing, but it may help ease the pain and suffering between fishing trips. We know that anglers love to fish, but let’s be honest—we cannot fish all the time. So when the angler cannot be on the water, what greater domestic pleasure can a fisherman derive than watching his wife mow the lawn? Watching his wife mow the lawn while Lawn Trout scurry playfully about the yard!

Mrs. UA mowing the lawn amidst a pod of Lawn Trout.

As Lawn Trout spread in popularity there will undoubtedly be some recreational landscapers who report sightings of Lawn Steelhead. These fanciful claims should be regarded with caution and skepticism. Without conclusive photographic proof, the authenticity of such outrageous claims cannot be accepted as truth. Do not trust grainy photographs or bad video footage as evidence of the existence of these mythical creatures.

Lawn Steelhead. Riiiight…

In addition to such ridiculous claims as Lawn Steelhead I suppose it’s certain to happen that with Lawn Trout would come less desirable species. There’s not much one can do about that so tolerance, if not outright acceptance, should be the yard owner’s goal as long as the undesirables aren’t damaging shrubbery. Some species, such as Lawn Grass Carp may even keep weeds in check and reduce the frequency with which your lawn needs mowing. And before you curse the presence of the Lawn Whitefish, remember–they may be an indication of a healthy yard. In fact, if you’ve got Lawn Whitefish, chances are you’ve also got a Blue Ribbon Lawn Trout Yard!

The misunderstood Lawn Grass Carp

The inevitable Lawn Whitefish

What of those burrowing vermin that were discussed earlier? Envision a 30-inch, hook-jawed meat eater lying in wait under a rhododendron for the sun to go down. As darkness falls and mole activity increases, the Brown Lawn Trout goes hunting. End of mole problem.

Mole-eating Brown Lawn Trout

My plan sounds remarkably foolproof but I will admit that the biggest challenge I see facing Lawn Trout is the matter of air.  Fish need water over their gills in order to breath, and even though the Pacific Northwest gets more than enough rain to keep things soggy most of the year (which Crane Flies like), it’s probably not enough water to sustain Lawn Trout (except during floods). That being said, maybe a few decorative Lawn Trout statues strategically placed throughout the yard would suffice to keep the Crane Flies at bay and scare off the moles. They may not be as good as the real thing, but at the very least ornamental Lawn Trout would be a welcome alternative to other yard decorations, right?

Ornamental Lawn Trout, good. Others, bad.

 

{ 24 comments… read them below or add one }

Harry September 28, 2011 at 5:54 AM

Intriqing idea. We have a similar grub problem with Japenese beetles and moles, but I never would have thought of the lawn trout angle. Wonder if it would work with lawn smallmouth?

Reply

Kirk Werner September 28, 2011 at 12:28 PM

Harry, I see no reason why Lawn Smallmouth wouldn’t fit the bill, although Lawn Largemouth my be required if your moles are unusually big.

Reply

Ed September 28, 2011 at 7:28 AM

Great post Kirk! I almost went by the Chemical Warning Label — I’m glad that I looked at it. I remember a ‘fishing needs a Dirty Harry’ post that still holds my spot as #1. I’ll have to look it up in your archives.
-ed

Reply

Kirk Werner September 28, 2011 at 12:33 PM

Ed, first, thank you. Your praise validates me. I’m glad you took the time to read the Warning Label. I believe too often we glaze over those important disclaimers and miss the important messages hidden in the small text. Excellent recall on the Fly Fishing Needs Dirty Harry. I believe that may never be topped, at least not from the likes of the UA. It’s an entry that proved so lucrative that it drove me into retirement, afterall. Of course, that didn’t last long and here I am talking about other, important issues facing anglers and yard owners alike.

Reply

Derek Young September 28, 2011 at 8:40 AM

Dear Friend, you have created a masterpiece here, so much so that my motivation to write is now on hold. How can one compete with consenting insects, cat-eating bull char, and fish porn on a John Deere?

Well done, and my absolute vote for best blog of the century.

Derek

Reply

Kirk Werner September 28, 2011 at 12:34 PM

Oh, sir- you’re just being melodramatic now (and I like it). Thanks for the good word. By the way, you’re the same Derek Young who is the 2011 Orvis Endorsed Guide of the Year, the only Orvis Endorsed Guide in the State of Washington, and owner of Emerging Rivers Guide Services, aren’t you?

Reply

Derek Young September 30, 2011 at 12:17 PM

Shameless plug, but yes I am. By the way, there’s still some room on the guide calendar, and given the success of your last Yakima trip – well, I’m just saying that you might find yourself with nothing to do on a Monday in October, and come along.

Reply

Kirk Werner October 1, 2011 at 12:04 AM

I’ll have you know that I caught no fewer than 6 troots on my last Yakima trip, ranging in size from 2-10 inches. Are you suggesting that I achieved some sort of unaccomplishment?

Reply

cofisher September 28, 2011 at 10:33 AM

I had a similar problem here in Colorado except it was vols, not moles. It’s true…look it up. They are every bit as destructive. At first I thought it was a reference to the Tennessee Volunteers basketball team and sent off a nasty letter to the Governor of Tennessee, but he corrected me on my error. As you can imagine, as a Kentucky supporter, it was difficult to have to swallow my pride and apologize! Anyway, I’ve got vols and rat poison works. Of course there is the inevitable blowback…visits from the EPA, dead neighbor’s cats, dogs, birds and other non-essential living things. Anyway Kirk, thanks!

Reply

Kirk Werner September 28, 2011 at 12:39 PM

A simple and understandable misunderstanding on your part, Howard. I’d have written the same scathing letter that you did. All that being said, I highly recommend you consider introducing Lawn Trout to control your vol problem. Perhaps a native Lawn Greenback Cutthroat population would do well there?

Reply

TC/Trout Underground September 28, 2011 at 7:53 PM

Fortunately I was able to use advanced web geolocation technology to pinpoint your house, which made it a lot easier to notify the local mental health authorities about your apparent descent into madness.

I mean, you’re probably hearing voices too, right?

And besides, everyone knows that lawn grass carp only hang out on dried-out, brown lawns…

Reply

Kirk Werner October 5, 2011 at 12:06 PM

Tom, have you been conferring with Nurse Ratched? I don’t like her very much. Lawn Grass Carp- I’m just so sure…

Reply

Mrs UA September 28, 2011 at 9:14 PM

I like how I out-fish you even while fishing on the lawn! :)

Reply

Kirk Werner September 28, 2011 at 11:19 PM

Yeah, funny as a crutch Rich Mrs. UA. Tee hee hee.

Reply

Patrick September 29, 2011 at 8:24 AM

A day later I’m still reeling after reading this…

Reply

Kirk Werner September 29, 2011 at 10:47 AM

Better check the drag mechanism. If you’re still reeling, there may be a problem.

Reply

Sanders September 29, 2011 at 8:44 AM

I didn’t really understand your concept until I saw the diagram…thank you for putting that in for us visual learners. I wonder if my bulldogs could learn to fetch and release? unfortunately, the lawn trout may be too cagey for the likes of my two dimwitted friends.

You might even be able to bust out the lawn darts as a way to control the grass carp population…I’m liking this idea more and more :-)

Reply

Kirk Werner September 29, 2011 at 10:51 AM

I always have to account for the lowest common denominator, Sanders, and thus the technical illustration. I also consider myself amongst the lowest of the lowest common demonimators, so the diagram was as much for me as anyone else. I wouldn’t underestimate your dogs–Lawn Trout may awaken an intense fire that has previously appeared to have been extinguished. I like the lawn dart suggestion and shall acquire a set in anticipation of the need. Thanks for stopping by.

Reply

Fred Telleen October 1, 2011 at 7:31 PM

If you desire lawn Steelhead, then you must stop mowing the grass and maintaining a manicred lawn. They like it wild. Then you will have more cover for stalking and more time for fishing in general. Your yard can become a breeding ground for a diverse variey of species that will soon spread throughout the neighborhood. You could become a hometown hero and start a trend of letting all the lawns go wild. Or maybe they’ll just lynch you for being uncivilized. Tough call.

Reply

Kirk Werner October 3, 2011 at 11:52 AM

Fred, first off- good to hear from you. Hope AK treated you well. As to your allegations regarding a manicured yard and Lawn Steelhead, I believe you’d be right…and Wild Lawn Steelhead may become an important part of the green, organic movement. However, Lawn Hatchery Steelhead actually prefer a parked-out yard, which raises another very important matter: it’s essential not to confuse Wild Lawn Steelhead with Lawn Cement Pond Monkeys.

Reply

Steve Z October 3, 2011 at 5:25 PM

While I certainly see the appeal, I wasn’t on board until I saw the Bull Trout and the cat. I’m all for that sorta feline control. And tying up a few kitten flies would give one endless days of Bull Trout action. Perfect!

Reply

Kirk Werner October 3, 2011 at 10:18 PM

Steve, I realize that Lawn Trout would not be for everyone, but I think if people would take the time as you did to really see beneath the surface, that everyone will find something about Lawn Trout to embrace. And I doubt there’s a shortage of cat dubbing for your kitten flies. Purrrfect.

Reply

Charles August 20, 2014 at 6:10 PM

I’m not always patient enough to catch trout….perhaps lawn bluegill would fit the bill here in western PA!
Cheers!

Reply

Kirk Werner August 21, 2014 at 11:29 AM

If you’re patient, they will come.

Reply

Leave a Comment

Spam Protection by WP-SpamFree

Previous post:

Next post: